MASCARA | CoverGirl Total Tease mascara

$8+ for 0.21 oz / 6.5 ml

It's natural looking ish and not too clumpy. However...

Smudgety smudge smudge

MASCARA | L'Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise

I've seen some people say the wand is similar to Too Faced Better Than Sex, which I recently tried. I think the Too Faced is bigger but the two mascaras are quite similar.

Unfortunately neither of them wow me, they are good mascaras though.


$9+ for 0.28 oz / 8.5 ml

Natural looking lashes, could get a little clumpy (esp if your lashes aren't nicely separated)

Smudgety smudge

MASCARA | Almay Get Up and Grow Extreme Length

Not sure if you can tell... But the wand is HUGE. Like, longer than my eye

This was on clearance at Walmart for $3.50 so ofc I couldn't resist. 

I quite enjoyed this mascara bc it's natural looking. Except 2 hours in, it started smudging on my undereye. Granted, mascara will always smudge on me (that's just how my lashes roll) but 2 hours is a bit too fast.

Probably will pass this along to someone who doesn't have that problem 

MASCARA | Kiss Me Heroine Make Volume and Curl Mascara

Pros

Holds a curl very well

Volumnizing

Lengthening

Waterproof

Cons

Not that easily removable

Price

$15+ for 6 g

On Ebay

Verdict

I bought this mascara after seeing Catie from Youtube talk about it (she's a Taiwanese Youtuber). I have very thin lashes so I always enjoy a good volumnizing mascara. This mascara claims to be removable by facial cleanser... I tried the Philosophy Purity which is usually decent at removing makeup, and I ended up using eye makeup remover. So that part's a false claim, but the mascara itself is great.

Repurchase?

Likely

Would I recommend it?

Yes!

MASCARA | Kiko Extra Sculpt Waterproof Mascara

Price

$14 for 0.37 oz / 11 ml

Kiko has free shipping over $15 so that's always good

If you watch KathleenLights, you know this is probably her favorite mascara (although I think she uses the washable version)

Unfortunately, for my thin, straight, long ish lashes - these didn't even hold a curl!

They seem decently lengthening and volumnizing but a bit clumpy (as the formula seems a bit dry) and the wand is huge. If you always struggle with getting mascara on your upper lid, these would be a nightmare. It also seems to smudge on my under eye more so than my Maybelline mascaras. My favorite to use recently has been the Falsies Push Up Angel (review here). Honestly Maybelline just makes good mascaras.

All in all a fail :/ the curl-holding thing is VERY important. I actually saw an Asian Youtuber saying that the Extra Sculpt didn't work out for her, but waterproof mascaras at the least hold a curl, so I didn't take her word for it.

Repurchase?

No.

Would I recommend it?

Only if your lashes don't have problems staying curled.

MASCARA | Maybelline the Falsies Push Up Angel Waterproof

Maybelline's description:

The Falsies effect gets angel wings! Exclusive Push-Up Wing brush sweeps lashes to the side, while lifting and plumping from the roots.

Right eye

Left eye

It's not really separating, but it does make a difference on my lashes. Unfortunately it's not super defining so it "clumps" 2-3 lashes together to make like 10 clumps. I notice it's kind of hard to find a volumnizing mascara that doesn't clump a little bit, probably why I like Maybelline Lash Sensational so much

Price

$7-10 for 0.33 oz

Would I recommend it?

Sure

Would I repurchase?

Nah

MASCARA | Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Waterproof

Pros

Natural looking

Not clumpy

Cons

Not super volumnizing

Easily stains your eyelids

Price

$21 for 0.24 oz / 7 ml

Verdict

I'm not particularly taken with any high end mascaras, but this one seems to have good reviews so I was excited to try it. Upon application I wasn't disappointed, but my thin, long lashes could use the extra oomph that volumnizing mascaras offer. The packaging is cute ish but I've seen the purple jacket come loose in stores with the testers, so idk how sturdy they are. 

For some reason the brush (the way it's shaped or something) makes it really easy to stain your eyelids, so it could get a little messy

Had I not gotten this with a deal via Tarte, I probably would return this.

Repurchase?

No.

Would I recommend it?

If you like natural looking mascaras

MASCARA | Lancome Grandiose Waterproof

Verdict

I remember being really impressed by the washable version, but this one seems ok, I got it in the summer kit from Sephora. Not sure if it's super pigmented or what, it smudges more on my undereye than any other mascara I own.

 I still prefer my Maybelline Lash Sensational waterproof (review here). 

Price

$32 for 0.35 oz

See the washable review here

Would I repurchase?

No. 

Would I recommend it?

Sure.

MASCARA | Giorgio Armani Eyes to Kill Wet waterproof mascara

Sephora

What it is:
A 24-hour wear, volumizing and waterproof mascara. 

What it does:
Get waterproof, lush lashes in just one swipe. This all-in-one mascara provides volume, length, and definition, and it’s formulated with fine, fluid Microfil technology for intensely captivating lash texture. The micro-waxes are blended with a fineness agent to allow for smooth and easy application, creating lightweight volume and length. The oversized patented lash brush features a bristle weave design that coats and texturizes lashes in less strokes—creating a striking lash look that lasts all day. 

What else you need to know:
The patented asymmetrical applicator allows for the optimal amount of formula to be loaded onto the brush.

Top | Bare curled lashes

Middle | 1 coat 

Bottom | 2 coats

My left lashes are shorter and thinner, so I like to wipe off less mascara when I take out the wand to give more volume.

Pros

Defining

Smudges less than any mascara I've tried

Natural looking

Very waterproof

Holds a curl well

Cons

Makes lashes feel brittle

Expensive

Price

$32 for 0.22 oz 

Verdict

If you often have mascara smudging on your undereye (like me), you'll appreciate the lasting power of this mascara in terms of smudging. Raeview says it's budge proof, which might be true depending on how oily/moist your eye area is. It's definitely waterproof but not entirely oil proof (which makes sense, bc how else would we remove it). 

Personally I like mascaras that can be built up all at once (like the Maybelline Lash Sensational that I so often mention), instead of waiting for it to dry between coats like the GA. I wasn't wowed by 1 coat but 2 coats definitely do the trick. I actually purchased this full price when I was in Vegas (shocking, I know) and I surprisingly reach for it all the time over my other drugstore mascaras that I love. If I want really dramatic lashes I'll still go to Maybelline, but for a long lasting natural lash - Giorgio Armani is the way to go. 

Repurchase?

Maybe.

Would I recommend it?

If you don't mind the price point this is definitely a good mascara to try

MASCARA | CoverGirl Katy Kat waterproof mascara in Very Black

The bristles spiral around the wand, not sure if it does anything but it doesn't clump on my lashes, which is good

Bare lashes > 1 coat > 2 coats

I noticed my left eyelashes always photographs better, the overall length is more consistent and they don't look all crazy

Pros

Lengthening

Doesn't clump

Natural looking

Neutral

Dry formula

Cons

Could fan out the lashes more

Price

$8 for 0.35 oz / 10.5 ml

Verdict

I am pleasantly surprised by this mascara. I honestly just bought it bc it's new and the tube is cute, but any mascara that makes my lashes visible on top of eye makeup without clumping is good in my book. I think this is comparable to my holy grail (the Maybelline Lash Sensational, review here), although the CoverGirl has a much drier formula, so it depends on what formula usually works better for you.

This Super Sizer (review here) is a bit more volumnizing but it clumps too much for my taste.

This mascara will be available in stores in July, I bought mine off Amazon.

I know it seems like I try a lot of mascaras, I love my Maybelline ones but I can never resist new things with cute packaging. This mascara also comes in blue, but not waterproof so I passed

Repurchase?

Yes.

Would I recommend it?

Yes.

Minimal smudging - I was pretty impressed, I reach for this more than my Maybelline Lash Sensational now. Although I find when I remove it w cleansing oil it tends to get in my eye?

REVIEW | Maybelline Colossal Spider Effect waterproof mascara

Closer look at the brush

If you curl your lashes right the first time, this mascara doesn't clump, good stuff

Pros

Very volumnizing

Cons

Could get clumpy

Not super lengthening

Price

$6+ for 0.32 oz / 9.5 ml

Verdict

Unfortunately, this isn't as lengthening as my holy grail Lash Sensational (review here). If you don't curl your lashes right it could get clumpy (by that I mean your lashes are all straight, not diagonal where it intersects with other lashes, as in the first lash photo). 

Otherwise it's very volumnizing, I like it!

Repurchase?

No, I will continue repurchasing the Lash Sensational.

Would I recommend it?

If you like a lot of volume and don't mind brushes your lashes out a bit.